Did you ever ruin somebody else’s joke in public?

I

1965, first day of seventh grade, new teacher, Mr. Pappert. He was deciding what to give us for homework: English or Math. He settled on English. Our assignment was to find an English word of eight letters that had only one vowel.

In my best Jerry Mathers voice, I said, “Sir, is it strength?” “Why, yes it is,” he replied. “Fiddlesticks, I have to find some math problems.” This provoked outrage in the classroom, all directed at me. “Elden!” they cried, in tones that suggested they knew I was going to do that. Some of them were still writing the assignment down in their little green notebooks.

II

1995. My evening Evidence class had not done well explaining Adams v. Baker and Charlie v. Delta. The professor, Dr. Hornstein, was not pleased with us, and warned us all about showing up in class the next time without knowing Echo v. Foxtrot and Giant v. Hawaii backwards and forwards. That day came, and as he started the class, Professor Hornstein said, “We’ll get to cases in a minute, but first I would like to read something I read on the Internet today that I think will amuse you.” It was a story about the whale that had washed up on the beach in Oregon, and I interrupted his reading to say, “Oh yeah, that’s when ODOT decided to get rid of it by blowing it up with dynamite, and wrecked a couple of cars in the process.” He stopped reading, and turned to me with an expression guaranteed to curdle milk, and asked if he could continue. “Sure, go ahead,” I said. “I’m sure it’ll be fine.” He did, but the moment was lost, and it was his turn for charity titters.

Then he turned fully to me, arms akimbo, and the other students were edging away from me so they didn’t get caught in the crossfire. “Mr. Carnahan,” he said. “Do you have time to surf the Internet after doing all the reading for this class?” As it happened, I did—part of my job at NSA in those days was to survey parts of the Internet that might contain information useful to our analysts. So I replied, “Why, yes I do.” “Good,” he answered. “So you can tell us all about Echo v. Foxtrot, and then you will do Giant v. Hawaii as well.”


7 responses to “Did you ever ruin somebody else’s joke in public?”

  1. I love this, Elden! It made me laugh and also made me recall a few times in meetings where I could have spoiled the joke but did not. After reading this blog, I wish I had spoiled the joke.

    Like

  2. You should have one-upped him with “strengths.”

    Like

  3. Natalie Bailey Avatar
    Natalie Bailey

    I can’t believe he assumed that everyone didn’t already know about the whale in Oregon! It’s a classic!

    Like

  4. I’m not a cat person, but would never drown one. My grandfather, a farmer in Missouri (pronounced missourah) had no use for them, and would tie a litter inside a burlap sack, and toss it into the catfish pond. Not sure the catfish liked it, either.

    Like

    1. Oops, I seem to have entered this in the wrong place; apologies.

      Like

  5. Such a smartass, you!
    Meanwhile, can April (perhaps in the captions) specify the prompts that generated the pictures? It’d be interesting to see how those words were interpreted (or possibly ignored).

    Like

  6. Beverley Sharp Amberg Avatar
    Beverley Sharp Amberg

    Thanks so much, Elden (and April!) for sharing these great stories with us. I will think of you every time I need some extra S-T-R-E-N-G-T-H (which is, basically, every day!) Please keep entertaining us!

    Beverley

    Like

Leave a comment

About THE BLOG

Thanks for making your way to the The Days of Wine and Roses, and Vasectomies, the personal blog of Elden Carnahan. My dad has been composing these stories as long as I can remember, either on paper or aloud around the dinner table. “You should put all your vignettes together into a book so we can sell it,” my mother would suggest from time to time.

For Christmas 2021, my sister gave Dad a Storyworth account–an online writing platform that sends you a weekly writing prompt in the form of a question. After a year or so of questions, the responses are all assembled into a hardback book. Dad took on the challenge with gusto, answering scores of questions, which often lent themselves to retellings of some of his favorite vignettes.

We’re using this blog to deliver the stories to a broader audience. Some of the posts are direct answers to Storyworth’s questions; others are stories that he wrote for other purposes. I’ll try to provide context and explanation where appropriate. Many of the images accompanying these stories were produced using DALL-E artificial intelligence, using prompts related to the stories.

Please feel free to engage with us by leaving comments, and enjoy!

-April (daughter of Elden)

Newsletter